Is Tuition Really THAT Unreasonable in Ontario?

Windsor doesn't do mandatory co-op... not last I checked.

And you're right that 4 month co-ops don't do much. In my company, you'd barely scratch the surface after 4 months. McMaster pushed 16 month co-ops a lot. It was a great way to pay off your education before you graduated, and secure a job for graduation.

It's hard finding an engineering job. I was out of work for 8 straight months following University, and I have a respectable amount of education (College and University) and experience (tinkering with cars all my life). My friend took up work as an electrician for 2 years before he started working with me, but I look at that and see many opportunities for me to use that knowledge.

OSPE stopped doing entry level engineering pay surveys years ago because it was reflective of what was out there (or so I was told). The first offer my ex received (yes, she was also a Mechanical Engineering graduate) was $13/hr... She didn't take the job.

If you're willing to do so, you can find work in Alberta for a few years and then move back home. There are other options, just don't give up hope if that's what you want to do.

What field did you graduate in?

I think the point of the 4 month work term is so the student can experience different companies to figure out what and where they want work.....sometimes the students have been coming back to the same company because they like it and would like to work there upon graduating.

I took the first job I was offered, the pay was very low but working at the NRC for Pratt&Whitney paid off and opened up opportunities.
 
Last edited:
If you're willing to do so, you can find work in Alberta for a few years and then move back home. There are other options, just don't give up hope if that's what you want to do.

What field did you graduate in?

The issue isn't really with giving up hope. The issue is that I no longer know if this is what I want to do with my life. I so rarely have the opportunity to really get deep into the actual engineering work that the job isn't rewarding. I spend most of my time dealing with stupid crap or working on stuff that is pointless because drawings are out of date.... but we're contractually obligated to do the work... even though it'll never get used.

I'm in mechanical engineering.
 
The issue isn't really with giving up hope. The issue is that I no longer know if this is what I want to do with my life.

You're not the only one. When I was in grad business school, half the class were engineers looking for a career change.
 
You're not the only one. When I was in grad business school, half the class were engineers looking for a career change.

Engineering is a tough industry, and a lot of the people I graduated with only went into that program because they didnt know what they wanted to get into in terms of work. For some reason people equate "engineering" to doing "cool stuff" or something. The reality is that, outside of manufacturing jobs, mech engineers are usually just there to take on liability LOL. While the diploma can open doors for you, it also won't get you high paying jobs unless you take on high level management positions. The engineers i know that are getting paid a lot are usually managers or project managers in non-engineering companies. Business degrees or mba's cam go a long way in those positions.
 
Tuition is not too bad in Ontario, we still only pay a portion of the actual costs (my guess less than half)--many seem to forget that it costs more than what we pay, the tax payers are paying the rest (subsidizing to schools). University Tuition is actually cheaper than a private high school (even some private grade schools)!

The other costs of living must also be considered (rent, food, etc.), it all adds up and the other costs will likely be more than tuition. Figuring on ~10K in tuition, books etc. and another at least 10K in living costs (that is on the low side if you are going away to school) it is about 80 to 100K to get a degree. That drops to 40K if you can live at home, more on this later...

When someone graduates with a degree (or college diploma, or trade) that pays well the investment in tuition and other costs can be paid off with out much trouble. When someone gets a degree in a field that has no jobs or pays slightly more than minimum wage, well they are in for some hurt... Of course this is a choice!

If someone moves to the US after getting a degree they still pay for the tuition etc. but the subsidized costs are lost. They do not pay taxes to the government that subsidized their education. So we need to find a system where the cost is less of a barrier and the subsidies are less likely to be lost, this is not easy to do!

Since a society of highly paid workers is good for the tax base I would like to see the following implemented, it is some outside the box thinking. Give out student loans more "freely" but have an accelerated payback scheme that takes 20% of your provincial and federal income taxes PAID and applies this amount as forgiveness to the loans each year. To get the forgiveness the loans must also be in good standing and you must also be paying the taxes in the jurisdiction that you went to school in (the jurisdiction that subsidized your education). For example, if someone out of school is paying 20K in income tax (say 10K fed and 10K prov to make it easy) they would get 2K forgiveness from the province and 2K from the feds. Now if they went to school in Ontario and now work in Alberta they would only get the 2K fed amount. If they decide to work in the US, they get nothing...

The reason for having the forgiveness based on jurisdiction is the subsidized costs. Tuition is not the full cost, the governments kick in the rest. If someone gets a degree in Ontario, the government (tax payers) have paid a good portion of the "hidden" costs. If the student paid the full costs Tuition would be more than double today's amount. If they graduate and leave, that money was wasted (from a tax base perspective). Tying the forgiveness to the jurisdiction adds incentive to stay. Having the amount tied to income tax will help steer people towards higher paying fields.

In the above example they get 4K per year of the loan forgiven. Plus they have to be making the min payments on the loan. That 4K per year would be 20K in five years and 40K in 10. it is not a lot BUT it comes off the P on the loan so it works out to be a big deal in the end. The governments benefit from the added incentive to stay (less brain drain, less waste of university subsidies) and the extra tax base in the long run.

As for the cost of living. We chose to buy a house on the subway in Toronto. One of the main reasons, our kids will have access to three Universities and numerous colleges while living at home. For two kids that will save ~100K in living expenses by the time they go to school. I would rather put 100K into a mortgage than into rent etc. for them near the schools. If they choose to move away for school, they will pay the extra costs (we will pay tuition, books etc. only). Food for thought when buying a house.
 
Last edited:
Engineering is a tough industry, and a lot of the people I graduated with only went into that program because they didnt know what they wanted to get into in terms of work. For some reason people equate "engineering" to doing "cool stuff" or something. The reality is that, outside of manufacturing jobs, mech engineers are usually just there to take on liability LOL. .


I always wanted to design cars....In the beginning of my career I quit a salaried job in Canada to take a contract job with an auto company in Michigan. A year later I was salaried at the Saturn Tech Center on a the design team for the Saturn Vue and later other vehicles. Since then Ive worked on the new Cseries aircraft being developed by Bombardier and new large motors at GE. It's been cool so far!
I owe a lot to that move to Michigan, which was Not easy to do since my family is in the Gta.
 
I always wanted to design cars....In the beginning of my career I quit a salaried job in Canada to take a contract job with an auto company in Michigan. A year later I was salaried at the Saturn Tech Center on a the design team for the Saturn Vue and later other vehicles. Since then Ive worked on the new Cseries aircraft being developed by Bombardier and new large motors at GE. It's been cool so far!
I owe a lot to that move to Michigan, which was Not easy to do since my family is in the Gta.

That's why I got into the program as well, but one year in the auto industry working for Magna soured me on the entire idea. :p

I do construction now. It's a really good industry and some of these female architects are pretty hot haha.
 
That's why I got into the program as well, but one year in the auto industry working for Magna soured me on the entire idea. :p

I do construction now. It's a really good industry and some of these female architects are pretty hot haha.

Belinda Stronach was a bit of a milf though. No meetings at parties?
 
The issue isn't really with giving up hope. The issue is that I no longer know if this is what I want to do with my life.
I once read a book called "What colour is your parachute". It talks about finding a job doing what you want. I was so frustrated at not finding the job I wanted, I threw the book in the garbage... 6 weeks later I was given a job offer for the job that I wanted that I applied to using the techniques listed in the book. I applied to my current job when I had the book, but lost patience with it and threw it out. Now that I work for the company, I can see why it took a while to hire me.

Send me a PM and let me know what you're looking for in an engineering position and I'll keep my eyes open. I can't make any promises though.

Engineering is a tough industry, and a lot of the people I graduated with only went into that program because they didnt know what they wanted to get into in terms of work. For some reason people equate "engineering" to doing "cool stuff" or something. The reality is that, outside of manufacturing jobs, mech engineers are usually just there to take on liability LOL.
You're right. The real money comes once you are in a position to accept liability, or are in a managerial role within a company. When looking for work, my professors asked me to do a Masters. I politely declined as I wanted industry experience. I am now considering furthering my education (MBA, M.Sc., Law, PMP...), although I love engineering and would love to stay in this field (and even stay with my current employer). Now I want to build on it.

Tuition is not too bad in Ontario, we still only pay a portion of the actual costs (my guess less than half)--many seem to forget that it costs more than what we pay, the tax payers are paying the rest (subsidizing to schools).
Last I heard, student pay between 1/3 and 1/2 of the actual cost of an education. And I guess this brings us back to the topic of tuition cost...

For smart students, Ontario Universities do compete and give out scholarships. I knew a few friends in High School that got a "free ride" through University because their marks were so high. I'm sure one's a surgeon by now and the other... who knows, but he's doing whatever he wanted to do. And I personally agree with academic scholarships. We only benefit our schools and society when we provide people with the tools and education they need to accomplish their goals.

There are also low-income scholarships, and many other forms of reducing tuition for the average student, but it's not enough. Tuition should be slightly more reasonable. Maybe $4k - $5k per year?

I agree that perhaps not every degree is warranted and some are only obtained for the sake of obtaining a degree, but the english and philosophy degrees out there are stepping stones for advanced degrees which do have a lot of value in our society.
 
Maybe I'm part of the problem...but the (original) plan is to go to law school. Tuition's about 20k so when I save for it, I'm aiming for 25k by the time I'm eligible (which is more than generous). I've figured out a plan to save up that much and increase my income every year to adjust for the increases in the costs of living and I have a back-up plan for my back-up plan. So some foresight goes a long way.

I'm not so sure it's the tuition costs, but more the "have my cake and it, too" attitude that my generation seems to have with things. People want good grades and want to party (which is possible if you give up work). But they're not willing to pick and prioritize to make the sacrifice. I gave up a lot of extra-curriculars to work, but I'm not willing to completely give up a social life, so I trained my body to function just as well on less sleep. It just seems that there are so many factors that people CAN control, but they focus on the ones they most likely can't (ie rising tuition fees) just so they can be the victim. I know plenty of people who make it work while making half of the wrong choices (which they admit, too). So all you pretty much have to do to stay afloat is not make too many retarded decisions in your everyday life.

But then again, I'm also thinking it's because of people like me who try to find a way to make it work that the prices go up without enough people complaining?

This is after just over a year. I only make $11/hr at my job, and during school can only work about 8 hours there. On top of that, my rent is $475 a month, plus food for me and my cats. Because of the money, I most likely will not be able to ride next year, which sucks. Oh, and that statement doesn't include the books, which are over $1000
I really hate to put you on the spot, but I feel like this is part of the problem: sure, you might have extracurricular activities and all of that, but if it's the job, then why the hell are you staying somewhere that can only spare you 8 hours a week? I get that some people have pets, but did you not figure that it was an added expense? Why not just leave them with your family if that makes more financial sense? Individual situations (which everyone has to deal with) aside, so many of these students put themselves in the position that they're in.


A lot of students are not able to attend a school in the city of their choice, a lot of students have to attend a school in another city becuase that is the school that offers the program they want or that is the school that accepted them. I could have stayed at home if I went to Mac but I would have been commuting 45 minutes each way every day. Add that to an already busy engineering class schedule and it doesn't really leave a lot of time for a PT job.

Having to live away from home is an unavoidable reality for many students. Now you have rent, food, utilities, etc being added to your expenses athough you likely won't need a car. You're lucky if you can get away with spending less than $600/mo for all that. Now you're on the hook for an extra $7200/yr. I worked 10 hours a week in a parking lot booth making $11/hr. If I were to have worked 20 hours a week I would have failed a few courses and required an extra year of university. But let's say, for the purposes of your argument, that one is able to work 20 hours a week at $12/hr. That works out to about $12,000/yr as you mention which falls about $3000 short of covering a students tuition plus living expenses.

Your point about program availability's a good one. But in the situation that you mentioned, with those numbers, you'd qualify for an on-campus job (and those aren't hard to get at all). I'd even actually say that they hand those out too easily at most universities. I would also say that a car's not necessarily the best option for getting to and from school. Sure, you pay the premium for getting there faster or whatever...but you could also take a bus (which would take longer), but you could study there and back every day (so you're doing something that you would've done anyway). So there's an extra couple thousand dollars in savings. It's cutting it close, but I'm only trying to show that your point's debatable.

I'm definitely willing to concede for the more rigorous programs, but I'd say that more than half of the programs in Uni aren't rigorous (I'm basing it off knowing plenty of people at different unis throughout Ontario in different/same programs and controlling for intelligence/work ethic/etc).

I also lol at how many people stay on res. for all 4 years when it's such a big difference to get roommates that you met in first year and splitting rent with them. I especially have no sympathy for these type of people.

I did my MA at McMaster. They did not cover any of the fees or travel costs I paid out to present at the ASA conference in NYC that year. The uni where I was working on my PhD did not cover any of the fees I paid out to present at UoIndiana. Neither subsidizes fees for belonging to professional affiliations. While I received a scholarship from both universities, the one from McMaster was quite small. The majority of my income came from teaching undergrad seminars. That work was also expected of us. The scholarship from the other university barely covered tuition and book costs. No costs of living, no additional academic type work, etc. I actually had to bow out of a major conference presentation in Oregon because I couldn't afford it, and my institution refused to cover a penny of the costs. Then I bowed out of another major conference in San Fran. It really ****** me off. Especially because you're presenting as a representative of your school and department. The more your face and research is seen, the more interest and outside research funding will come in. You're actually helping your department by presenting, but they don't make it easy for you.
I would definitely admit that post-grad students have more to protest for/have an easier cause to protest for across almost all programs, it seems pretty unreasonable for masters students. From what I understand now, you make x amount of money but a certain amount gets deducted for tuition costs. Then you have the mandatory teaching hours, marking papers, etc.

As a graduate of their engineering program, I can tell you right now that it's a cut-throat environment in there, and I don't see how anybody would be able to work a job that pays enough to cover tuition/books/food/etc., while maintaining the ludicrous workload and pressure that you're put under. Half of the TA's don't speak english and a good 2/3rds of the profs couldn't teach their way out of a paper hat. And I'm not even going to get into how inadequate my high school education was in preparing me for the material being covered in my first year of classes.
From what I've heard/people telling me, U of T's engineering program is pretty damn rigorous. I heard you guys even have rankings? At one of my jobs (one where you can actually study), this guy had to quit to focus on school so I know it has to be that bad. lol

As for the cost of living. We chose to buy a house on the subway in Toronto. One of the main reasons, our kids will have access to three Universities and numerous colleges while living at home. For two kids that will save ~100K in living expenses by the time they go to school. I would rather put 100K into a mortgage than into rent etc. for them near the schools. If they choose to move away for school, they will pay the extra costs (we will pay tuition, books etc. only). Food for thought when buying a house.
Lol you're so fuqed if they end up like most kids and want to go out of town just for the experience
 
Your point about program availability's a good one. But in the situation that you mentioned, with those numbers, you'd qualify for an on-campus job (and those aren't hard to get at all). I'd even actually say that they hand those out too easily at most universities. I would also say that a car's not necessarily the best option for getting to and from school. Sure, you pay the premium for getting there faster or whatever...but you could also take a bus (which would take longer), but you could study there and back every day (so you're doing something that you would've done anyway). So there's an extra couple thousand dollars in savings. It's cutting it close, but I'm only trying to show that your point's debatable.

I'm definitely willing to concede for the more rigorous programs, but I'd say that more than half of the programs in Uni aren't rigorous (I'm basing it off knowing plenty of people at different unis throughout Ontario in different/same programs and controlling for intelligence/work ethic/etc).

I also lol at how many people stay on res. for all 4 years when it's such a big difference to get roommates that you met in first year and splitting rent with them. I especially have no sympathy for these type of people.

An on campus-job? You mean like the students that work for the university handing out parking tickets? Those jobs that offer 20 openings a year and have 3000 applicants? Yes, I am sure i would qualify for those jobs too just like all the other applicants.

So which bus would I have taken from Kibride to Mac every day? Which bus would someone that lives in Brantford, Waterdown, Milton or anywhere that's not Hamilton take to Mac every day? You can't save money by taking a bus if there is no bus for you to take. I already addressed the point about potential students living within bussing distance, my point was regarding those who are not. Swing and a miss.
 
Belinda Stronach was a bit of a milf though. No meetings at parties?

I was never invited to those parties :p

I guess my golf game wasn't advanced enough.
 
From what I've heard/people telling me, U of T's engineering program is pretty damn rigorous. I heard you guys even have rankings? At one of my jobs (one where you can actually study), this guy had to quit to focus on school so I know it has to be that bad. lol

It's horrendous. I wasn't aware of a ranking system, but that's probably because I was never getting grades anywhere good enough to be ranked.

While I have absolutely no problem blaming people for being worthless, lazy idiots with entitlement issues, I can't say that this is the case for these protests. The industries call for university degrees, which forces students and families to go into huge amounts of debt on the idea that they might get a job after they graduate....if they graduate. It's an assbackward type of situation.

While some people may be able to get away with it, and others in the past have pulled it off successfully, working a job that allows you to maintain some type of standard of living while pursuing a highly technical degree in a rigorous program is a lose-lose situation. I do not wish that upon anybody LOL.
 
Western doesn't do mandatory co-op thing that Waterloo (and i think Windsor?) does. There are optional ones. I did a 12 month internship with John Deere Forestry in Product Validation and Verification after 3rd year but they announced that the plant was closing 6 months into my term. Super.

I believe that the 4 month placements do very little to actually teach the students anything other than office politics and TLA (three letter acronym) systems. I've been in my current job for 14 months now and still feel utterly lost sometimes. In a technical field like engineering you can't really get into anything serious in 4 months... and even in the 12 months I spent at John Deere all I was fed was ***** work.

There are more engineers in Ontario right now than the industry can support. I worked at Inglis Cycle for a year after graduating because the job market was (and still is) garbage. I moved back to Burlington and worked at National Steelcar for 2.5 years, I did not enjoy that job. I took a pretty large pay cut to move back to London and I'm making less now than I was 4 years ago. I'm still a contract worker so I get no benefits, no bonus, no rrsp program. I made more money building fences and decks as a summer job than I do now. The current state of the industry is such that junior engineers are underpaid. There is sweet **** all I can do about it, if I don't want to do the job there are 10 other recent grads that will. Actually there are probably 1000. But I have been thinking about leaving the industry altogether.

If you don't mind working heavy construction (building dams, oil rigs, refineries, bridges, etc). I can forward your resume on with a good word. It's long hours but the pay is solid.
 
/
I also lol at how many people stay on res. for all 4 years when it's such a big difference to get roommates that you met in first year and splitting rent with them. I especially have no sympathy for these type of people.

your lol would be more valid if you didn't live at home. lol
 
Also the engineering market in Toronto is pretty solid. There is pretty much **** all in london
(at least for jobs that pay more than 50K). Not sure why some people think there isn't much work. All you need to do is type in "Toronto engineering jobs" in google and tons of **** comes up.

Also Tuition is freaken expensive. Whether you can save up to do it or not is inconsiquential because school would not be the same without the "perks". I find learned more about human interaction in the bars, than I ever did in my engineering class room. And I am finding increasingly that most jobs are about how well you can communicate with other people and coordinate, rather than how technically strong you are in a subject. In fact most very technically strong guys end up painting themselves into a corner and seem to get forgotten. This has been my experience working for two very large companies.
 
Freestyle, to speak to that... When hiring at my company, I rarely looked at grades (never asked for it). A degree was a degree. I looked for confidence in the interviewee, and I looked for extra curricular events while in school. Social skills are a considerable portion of this job.

An on campus-job? You mean like the students that work for the university handing out parking tickets? Those jobs that offer 20 openings a year and have 3000 applicants? Yes, I am sure i would qualify for those jobs too just like all the other applicants.

So which bus would I have taken from Kibride to Mac every day? Which bus would someone that lives in Brantford, Waterdown, Milton or anywhere that's not Hamilton take to Mac every day? You can't save money by taking a bus if there is no bus for you to take. I already addressed the point about potential students living within bussing distance, my point was regarding those who are not. Swing and a miss.
On a side note, Mac's tuition (actually, the compulsory student union fees) covered HSR usage.

There was also a GO bus to/from Mac multiple times per day. Unfortunately you'd have to be close to a GO terminal (not sure where the closest one is to Kilbride).

For those that live just outside the bus routes, your options are car-pooling, driving, or moving to off-campus housing.

Truth is, I don't know many engineering students that had the luxury of having a decent paying job with flexible enough hours. I had two different factory jobs over my time in school and I did homework DURING work hours numerous times.

As expensive as tuition is, it's not so expensive that somebody can't get a degree if they really want a degree. And if they can't afford to pay back OSAP, it will be forgiven (in portion) as it has in the past.
 
Last edited:
Also the engineering market in Toronto is pretty solid. There is pretty much **** all in london
(at least for jobs that pay more than 50K). Not sure why some people think there isn't much work. All you need to do is type in "Toronto engineering jobs" in google and tons of **** comes up.

.

General Dynamics is in London, Cami is nearby also?
 
Back
Top Bottom