Way too many hippies in the GTA.
I obviously fish. Typical line and a hook, used to spear fish as a kid with my dad, and I've bowfished (yes, using a bow and special arrow with a reel).
Ethics come in to play. We try to hook fish through the lips so they don't swallow the hook. Part of the reason is so that if the fish isn't a keeper, it will live if thrown back. We've had fish we would throw back due to size, but kept since they would have ended up dying so we kept them to eat.
Fish live after being thrown back if it was a simple hook through the lip/face.
It's the way the natural world is. Animals eat other animals... We're animals. Instead of getting my fish from a disease and mercury infested cess pool, I try to get mine from natural, clean water ways. My meat, I try to get that from naturally fed and exercised animals... If you want to eat "green" and organic, go out and kill it yourself.
If you don't agree with fishing (either for sport or commercially) or hunting, then enjoy your life of soy based foods and supplements because your body isn't getting what it requires.
FYI, commercial fishing is much more harmful to the environment than sport fishing.
There are many, many examples of VERY healthy vegetarians and vegans.
I hear even some UFC/MMA fighters are vegan or veg. Mac Danzig, Jake Shields, Nate Diaz...probably many more if i was to search a bit. There are also vegan body builders, and many cultures throughout history have lived long, healthy lives without eating meat. Plenty of info on the 'history of vegetarianism' and the benefits of a
plant-based diet on the internets if you are interested.
I have vegan friends who have raised their child with no meat for his entire life and he is the largest boy in his class (12 yrs old now) and incredibly smart and mature for his age.
B12 is the only vitamin or mineral that i know of that the body needs but can't be reliably supplied by a whole-food plant-based vegan diet...and usually only long-term raw vegans or pregnant women need to really be concerned about it since many vegan foods are fortified (soy milk, ect) There are tons of great-tasting
meat alternatives available now too... plus/// meat-eaters also suffer B12 deficiencies so it isn't really a 'vegan only' problem.
As for fishing---I don't think anyone would argue that a group of guys going out on a boat and catching a few fish is in the same universe as the commercial fishing trawler scooping half the ocean up behind it or, that a guy out hunting a deer is the same as a
factory full of pigs in crates.
To me, the problem is that the mentality behind hunting/fishing can be potentially desensitizing, and the act inflicts suffering/killing that is not always necessary. I think there are a large number of complicated and not-so complicated reasons why some like to hunt/fish (ancestral/camaraderie/meditative/fiscal or environment needs/psychological, etc) while others don't. My own thought is 'i don't NEED to cause suffering/killing, so why would i?'
That said- i think it is possible to dislike the action, but still respect the person. . I don't think humans want to live by the 'we are all animals/strong overpower and take from the weak' philosophy for the most part. Thankfully we are leaning towards more of a kinship-based community that has evolved and expanded over history.
I have been veg/vegan for over 25 years. I obviously don't expect everyone to come to all the same conclusions i have, and i definitely don't consider myself better than someone else...we all do what we think is right and live the only way we know how (or can).
One problem i see though- i don't think many people have a true picture of how truly horrible animals are treated in modern factory farms.
Our idyllic childhood image of what a farm is quite often
drastically different in real life. Especially when you are talking about
large volume suppliers. Family-based farms replaced by large production facilities. Other than the fact we are all 'animals', there is very little 'natural' in this. Hopefully this doesn't make me sound like a tinfoil hat wearer, but most of it is run by large fortune500 companies reaping huge profits- from the drugs, to the advertisers, to the retailers (and many in between). Most of us work hard and when we get home we don't want to think about this ****.
It would be great if we could all be making truthful, informed choices about food based on what we want to support- and what we don't when going shopping at the supermarket. I really don't think most people are cruel or indifferent to animal (or human) suffering at all. We do what we are brought up doing...and what we have learned.
As individuals, we all live unique lives with specifically personal experiences and have a genetic-given capacity to process these experiences- that then determines our actions as we live our lives....I grew up with pets, used to have band rehearsals at a buddies farm, and had several experiences through my life that led me to my decision. I didn't grow up in your body with your brain, and experience the same things as you (if i did- i'd do exactly what you do)...To expect everyone to be the exact same as me would be retarded (and pretty boring).
There is a great group called
Mercy For Animals who are like a sane version of PETA if anyone is interested. The have exposed a ****-load of animal abuse at some of the largest suppliers.
Sorry for the novel. Too much caffeine at work tonight.
On that note---Finding vegan motorcycle gear is really ****ing tough.