The boats your friends are looking at are probably more trouble than they are worth if home base is in Scugog. A 32' I/O cruiser will draft 30" drives up, 40" drives down, which limits operation in most of the lake to the nav channel.
They've had a 35' IO on Scugog for coming up on about 7 or 8 years now. It's perfectly fine, we can even belly it up to the sand bar without any issue. Yeah, you need to be careful when you're out of the chanel, but only a handful of times has water depth ever been an issue even in the chanel, about 4-5 years ago when they released way too much water out of the lake in the spring and then it was a dry summer.
Scugog has a bad reputation, but not all of it is warranted. Those who have spent any time on it know that it can actually be a nice lake. It's not Balsam or whatever, but it's also only 20 minutes from where we both live, so it's super convenient.
The only reason for what looks like will be a lateral move when it's said and done is that the current boat has an engine that has gone bad, and the boat may also be nearing end of life for other reasons so it may not make sense to repair, so moving up to something somewhat more modern as well at the same time also makes sense in the bigger picture.
Last edited: