What pickup truck do you use? | Page 9 | GTAMotorcycle.com

What pickup truck do you use?

You jumped into this conversation and assumed that at this point we're still talking about diesel pickups. There are other diesels out there that can do what have been discussing.

I'll replace all of my 6 glow plugs and have well north of 2.3K left in my pocket as i do all my own work and they are easily accessible.

My oil price quote included 10 quarts of fully synthetic 5w30 low ash 291.51 Mercedes spec'd oil designed for DPF's. Found locally at NAPA for $7 a quart vs 15 at dealerships. 20K is low workload prescribed change internval. 15K for higher workload.

You then go on to quote 10K in work totally unnecessary unless you plan on keeping the truck fora long time, and instead of amortizing the price over multiple years, you dump the truck in one?!

Thats like me saying "yea, i bought this Subaru Impreza, man what a ***** on maintenance and cost of running. You know i rebuilt the motor, installed bigger turbo, all new fuel system, a roll cage and top of the line aftermarket suspension so i can run Rally Racing. Then i sold it after a year. Never another Impreza man!!"

We get it, you dont like diesels....thats cool, statistically though, diesels put on way more km's than gassers. That construction worker who uses his diesel truck regularly with no issues, he doesnt go on internet forums and ******* about failed parts. He fills up and drives it. So maybe, just maybe the internet view on diesel maintenance is a bit skewed?

Replace all 8 glow plugs labour and tie up any loose ends and you won't get much back from 2.5k. I'm not sure what kind of truck you have, but I'm quite sure it wouldn't serve my purpose.
Also keep in mind that injectors and other items I listed will be well over $2.5k so your argument is moot.

I have a f450 that's built, I also have had lots of regular diesels that have been nothing but preventative maintence. They have still been well over $10k the first year between upgrading the hpop, egr, dpf delete tuner and exhaust and regular upkeep. Great trucks and once it was sorted it was great but small breakdowns would still wipe out any fuel saving. I usually buy one truck a year so keeping tabs might not be the easiest thing for you.

If you do your oil changes at 20k then I'm guessing we have different definitions of maintence or very different ideas of what a truck is.
Not sure where you are seeing a bias.

No shop that I would trust my trucks with will do a Dino oil change for less than $150, I use synthetic at $200. Modern diesels have ridiculous fuel contamination issues. I would suggest looking into it.
Take a whif of what your oil smells like at 20k and let me know if you still think that's somewhere you want to save money.

$15k.. Have an injector stick open at 20,000 psi and I want to see what your bill is. Mine took out a 6 month old $45k engine build.

I do know a bit about diesel trucks I run them 90k a year and have been for quite a while.
I was like you the first couple of years and believed they were the greatest thing since sliced bread.. After sitting down and doing the math its really not the case.

the old diesels 7.3 and 12v were awesome but dont fool youself into thinking the modern diesels are the same. I know if a ton of cummins 6.7s that have had headgaskets swapped, etc.
Power-strokes 6.0 egr, HPOP issues. 6.4 broken pistons are the norm.
duramax - 2000-2005 were nightmares for injectors. I knew a guy that had pit on 5 sets by the time he was at 200k and he wasn't the only one. Don't know about current duramax trucks.

Guys that have been running much larger fleets than me for way longer than me are swapping over to gas, there is a reason behind it. Watching a gas tow truck tow away my diesel for the third time gave me something to ponder, lol.





No no, not biased at all....:rolleyes:

Glow plugs are $2.5K!?!

I mean, if you at least threw up some reasonable prices i could maybe agree with you, but with your exaggerated pricing, you lost any and all credibility.

Let me tell you what my costs for running a diesel are.

$95 oil changes that are schedules at 20K! I change it at 17K just to be on the safe side

Super duper expensive glow plugs for a super duper rare Mercedes engine? $22 each.

Gee, running diesels is so much more expensive and yet everyone and their mother is switching to Sprinter Vans with the 2.7 and 3.0 diesels as they are that much more economical to run than Gasser vans.

Dont be an idiot with a diesel and it will last you a lot longer than a gasser.

How much of your $15K cost has been go fast goodies and or things you broke due to pushing the engine limit? On one end you admit to 1200hp diesel and on the other end you ***** about reliability?
 
Thanks for the input fawaz. I wouldn't be doing 90k a year though, more like 15-20k tops...1/5 of the use, 1/5 of the repairs/maint. In theory anyway
 
I'll have to correct you and then pretty much bail on this as I think intelligent conversation is a passing dream.

You jumped into my reply to Kellen who has a half ton truck. He puts his racebike in the back of it. I am talking to Kellen about trucks. You are the only one that isn't talking about trucks. Unless Kellen can put his bike in the back of whatever you drive your responses have been nothing more than irrelevant arrogant and rude.

If you aren't talking trucks replying to me makes no sense. We aren't talking about your TDI, sprinter or what have you . If Kellen can't put his bike in the back it won't serve the purpose I was talking to Kellen about. (He can put one in a sprinter but will look like a plumber)

The $10k is what I initially spend to make a used diesel truck right so that I can put reliable comfortable mileage on it. I still spend anywhere from $3-5k in a 90k year long period. I can justify this as a breakdown while I'm pulling a trailer to the track can be a $20k loss in a single day for me. Getting all the big issues sorted is peace of mind. This is not the same as souping up a Subaru to go rallying, I'm not sure why you would suggest that.

An example of this maintenance paying off is my 6.0 seeing 600k on it when I sold it. It now has 750k and is still running great. Please let me know if your maintenance schedule has yielded similar results. It just costs a lot for upkeep and preventative maintenance and you won't see the return in fuel savings.

For what it's worth I am a pretty huge diesel fan. Difference is that I have enough experience with them to know the facts. I've cited real world numbers, real world problems from people I know not internet legend.
I've given problems with each of the big 3 and I've also mentioned that the older generations of diesels were damn near bulletproof. The current generations not so much.

I have also given you my actual operational costs for a gas and diesel trucks that I ran last year.
 
Until you get to the first corner. :)

With 4.88 gears I will be lucky if I make it to the corner. :)

It'll do a 12.1 in the quarter with me driving, I'm sure someone that didn't pay to repair it could get it safely in the 11s.
Not crazy fast but its a 11,000lb daily driven truck that I take my family to the track pulling a 14,000lb trailer. lol

Lets not pretend for a second that the thing is practical though or a representation of a regular diesel truck. Its a toy and I treat it as such.
 
Last edited:
The problem with the Ford diesels isn't that it's a diesel, it's that it's a Ford diesel. Ford seemingly can't figure out how to make a decent diesel engine.

The emission control hardware has been an issue with all of the pickup-truck diesels, but once they get this figured out, they should be OK again. It might take until the next design generation ...

My VW diesel cost no more to maintain than a gasoline VW would have and I sold it with just short of 430,000 km on it. But I'm skipping the first generation of VW common-rail (full emission control) diesel engines. They have had issues - but we already know enough about the next generation VW TDI engines (referred to as EA288, coming with Golf 7 next year) to see that they've fixed a few things.

The diesel particulate filter needs to be close-coupled to the engine. The path from cylinder head through turbo to catalyst/DPF has to be as short as possible. The trucks have it sitting underneath - it's too far downstream and it won't run as hot down there - the DPF needs to run as hot as possible. VW got the DPF placement right on clean-diesel version 1.0 (on TDIclub we've seen very few DPF problems) but they screwed up the low-pressure EGR system (fixed on Passat, will be fixed with EA288 ), and Bosch screwed up the design of the injector pump (Passat has it "sortafixed" but it seems good enough). EA288 will have the entire emission control system directly attached to the engine - it's built into the design, not added on afterward.

VW's DPF location works with a transverse inline-four. An inline-six will have a longer path, and a V8 with two banks of cylinders is an even bigger challenge, and if the engine is sitting lengthwise between frame rails that's another complication - but Audi, Mercedes, and BMW cars have the engine lengthwise, and the various DPF-equipped Audi and Mercedes V6 and BMW I6 diesels don't seem to be having issues with them ...
 
Last edited:
Jeez $2.5K for glow plugs? Cost me $20 for all 4 when I had a diesel (TDI, I will admit). And thought the guy I met in for service once that paid them $800 for a replacement got ripped.
 
Cummins = no glow plugs.

6BT Cummins = all mechanical. No fancy electronics or emissions control crap.

6BT Cummins into a 1978 Ford chassis = Approx 10L/100km
 
While we are talking diesels. My 24v Cummins has been a rock star. It can drag a loaded trailer 4 hours from Bowmanville to Grand Bend at 120kph for 40-50 bucks depending on traffic. I do my own oil changes 10L plus a filter. Fuel filter and air every second oil. In 200K I replaced a waterpump (the coolant cost more than the pump and took 20 min), As most know my truck lives with a trailer in tow couldnt ask for better will NEVER own another gas truck and may drive this one until one of us is done :eek: . The truck starts in all weather. I have fired it at -26 with no issue. The block heater plug still has the factory cover (2004) never been plugged in. Dont even use fuel conditioner. What everyone is yakking about maint I dont see it.
 
Your 5.9 is the only diesel truck I would still ever consider buying!
Sell it to me ... :)

While we are talking diesels. My 24v Cummins has been a rock star. It can drag a loaded trailer 4 hours from Bowmanville to Grand Bend at 120kph for 40-50 bucks depending on traffic. I do my own oil changes 10L plus a filter. Fuel filter and air every second oil. In 200K I replaced a waterpump (the coolant cost more than the pump and took 20 min), As most know my truck lives with a trailer in tow couldnt ask for better will NEVER own another gas truck and may drive this one until one of us is done :eek: . The truck starts in all weather. I have fired it at -26 with no issue. The block heater plug still has the factory cover (2004) never been plugged in. Dont even use fuel conditioner. What everyone is yakking about maint I dont see it.
 
Diesel trucks vs porsche. Million Dollar maintenance. 1200 hp and practical in the same sentence. Someone pass the popcorn sprinkled with crack.

Sent from my SM-N900W8 using Tapatalk
 
You dont know what you're talking about! CLEARLY, you're lying as superstar who spends 10K a year in upgrades considers that "maintenance cost" has spoken and declared diesels as ****.

While we are talking diesels. My 24v Cummins has been a rock star. It can drag a loaded trailer 4 hours from Bowmanville to Grand Bend at 120kph for 40-50 bucks depending on traffic. I do my own oil changes 10L plus a filter. Fuel filter and air every second oil. In 200K I replaced a waterpump (the coolant cost more than the pump and took 20 min), As most know my truck lives with a trailer in tow couldnt ask for better will NEVER own another gas truck and may drive this one until one of us is done :eek: . The truck starts in all weather. I have fired it at -26 with no issue. The block heater plug still has the factory cover (2004) never been plugged in. Dont even use fuel conditioner. What everyone is yakking about maint I dont see it.
 
kneedragger88 got the optimum possible truck.

Cummins engine, the best one. Transport trucks use inline-sixes, not V8's, for good reason.
Pre-2007 so no DPF headaches.
Manual transmission so no Chrysler automatic transmission headaches.
No "killer dowel pin" ...

That is ONE thing with the 12-valve Cummins engine that needs to be taken care of. Google it. Plenty of info on how to prevent this problem in advance. If that pin ever comes out, it gets into the timing gears and wreaks havoc. There's a kit to fix the situation so that it will never happen. Only affects the 12-valve engines '89 - '98, so Ken's truck is fine.
 
Last edited:
The fix for the KDP is very very simple though.

The 12 valve is ideal for doing a diesel conversiom due to its simplicity but the 24 valve makes more power.
 
Cummins = no glow plugs.

6BT Cummins = all mechanical. No fancy electronics or emissions control crap.

6BT Cummins into a 1978 Ford chassis = Approx 10L/100km

My uncle is throwing a 4BT in to a 78(ish) Cherokee. Gonna be a fun project!
 
What do you guys think about a RWD pick up?
The only reason I was considering a 4x4 is so that I can get anywhere I need to in the winter months.
But realistically speaking, will a RWD be a pain or what?
 
I have always had rwd trucks and never had any issues 4x4 is not needed in so in my opinion. If you get a rwd with a locker it will be almost unstoppable. I currently have a rwd canyon with a 5.3 and a Silverado with a 4.3 and have never needed 4x4. I drive around for work most days in all weather, I do have snow tires on the canyon.

Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk
 
I drive an 05 dodge ram 2500hd, cummins 5.9l rwd. Before that I had an 03 ram 1500 4.7l v8 rwd. Four 24"x30" patio stones for winter weight, Goodyear wrangler territory a/t tires, no problems. The ram 1500 was great truck, but the 2500 diesel is miles ahead, easily twice the mileage form the same 134l tank, and I can pull anything. 4x4 is great, but expensive and unnecessary. Oh, I live near Barrie and spend the bulk of the winter in muskoka area for work, my rwd sees alot of snowy cottage trail type roads.
 
I drive an 05 dodge ram 2500hd, cummins 5.9l rwd. Before that I had an 03 ram 1500 4.7l v8 rwd. Four 24"x30" patio stones for winter weight, Goodyear wrangler territory a/t tires, no problems. The ram 1500 was great truck, but the 2500 diesel is miles ahead, easily twice the mileage form the same 134l tank, and I can pull anything. 4x4 is great, but expensive and unnecessary. Oh, I live near Barrie and spend the bulk of the winter in muskoka area for work, my rwd sees alot of snowy cottage trail type roads.

What type are driving do you do when youre getting double the mileage in the diesel?
 

Back
Top Bottom