The more I hear about the cost of some of these trips people are taking, the more I come full circle to realizing how much value there is in cruising lol.
Did you check Pearson first however? It USED to be way cheaper flying out of Buffalo or Rochester, but I've found that there's no longer any deals if you look closer at Pearson now. I flew to Vegas and back 6-8 weeks back with my sister for $160 return on Flair, it was actually MORE expensive to fly out of NY when I looked.
Anyhow, if someone is looking for something
*completely* off the beaten path, my wife and I just got back from a week in Eleuthera, a little off the radar island of the Bahamas. We've sailed past it on a bunch of cruises in the past, but honestly, it had never for a second been on my radar as a destination until a family member planned a destination wedding there. And in a matter of 12 weeks, it was planned, and we were on our way!
If you are an introverted beach bum, this place is literally heaven on earth. There was times where we had literally
kilometers of beach
entirely to ourselves. The absolute busiest beach we saw had maybe 5 other people on it, and that was multiple kilometers long, so you might as well have been alone in the end. A lot of beaches we WERE alone on.
View attachment 66090
View attachment 66091
View attachment 66092
There's 130 (yes, 130!) beaches in Eleuthera, on an island that's basiclaly only 100km long, and at it's widest 1.6km wide, and at it's narrowest, literally 1 lane of road. On one side it's dark blue Atlantic ocean, and on the other it's bright teal caribbean style ocean, and at more than a few places you can stand on the island and literally see both different colours by just looking left and right. It's a beach bums wet dream.
It's a very isolated island with basically almost everything having to come in by boat or plane. There is effectively no production there whatsoever and the economy is almost entirely reliant on tourism. EVERYTHING is expensive - a case of beer is $60 B$, which is $60USD, so basically $100 CAD. Our first grocery shop yielded us enough food for about 2 dinners and 2 brekfasts for our group of 4 was $260 after exchange. All meats are frozen, and selection is limited - medicre steaks were $30+ each, so we passed on that and went with hamburgers, ground chuck (tacos, etc), and were pretty creative - a lot of things you just can't get so some fancier meals were just not possible. Snack foods? $18 for a bag of chips, $8-$10 for a pack of cookies, etc. 2 people eating out anywhere was $80-$100, easily up to $200 if you ordered a few apps and drinks at some of the fancier resorts. Gas, $2.40/L or so after exchange. The rental vehicles range from actually pretty nice right hand drive micro SUV's (which we had, we lucked out big time with our choice of places to rent from) to absolute crates that would be pulled off the road here, and were barely functional.
Anyhow, it was an adventure and we had a great week, but you need to bring deep wallets and have realistic expectations on many things, it is still very much the bahamas, and if you've ever been there, you know. The electricity was out more than a few times (we did have an unfortunate storm for basically 2 days, so that played havok on their already often problematic power grid), the water system was out once, the Queens Highway (the islands equivalent of the 401, or more like highway 2) is a bit hairy in places and the locals drive fast, but if you're assertive and not afraid to clip along, it's fine I was laughing with some of our family from out west and south that I drive the 401 every day, so nothing scares me lol.
We were at a mult-unit AirB&B with 3 villas and it was excellent. Can't blame them for the power and water issues honestly, not the AirB&B's fault, but again, you need to understand this can happen in Eleuthera. With appropriate understanding and willingness to go with the flow, it's all good.
Takes some getting used to driving RHD vehicles on the left side of the road. But the locals were all super friendly, crime is very minimal, and what exists is petty stuff on that island, and there's no shortage of cool things to see and experience. And the beaches...oh my, the beaches.
Lots of unique restaurants on the island, as well as on Spanish Wells, the (higher-end) island just off the north shore, but again, bring your wallet.
We had absolutely the best (hands down) wings I have ever ate in my entire life at the French Leave resort in Governors Harbour, near where we were staying. Guava based BBQ sauce and, I, I don't know, crack, or something lol. Incredible. We are going to try to recreate the sauce as it was just insanely good. The meals were freakin delectable as well, I had a shrimp and sausage pasta in some sort of chipotle based sauce that was incredible as well.
Anyhow, with appropriate expecations for it being the Bahamas, and all the realities that come along with that, it's certainly a unique place to visit. I'd love to go again, but again, when compared against cruising, it's kind of hard to swallow the costs involved, and neither my wife or I are serious beach-bums, but I can certainly see the appeal for those who are.
Here's a panorama near the narrowest part of the island where it's 1 lane of traffic wide - standing on the rocks you can literally see the 2 different colours of the ecean from one side to the other. The picture doesn't even remotely do the colours justice - it's incredible in person.
View attachment 66093