Arguments in defense of this change all seem to rest on people's prediction of how we will use electronics in the future. There are two things to be said about this:
1- It may sound silly now given the speed of evolution of technology in the past several years, but people will choose to use cords for 100s, even 1000s more years. As long as wireless devices need charging, a significant number of people will opt for cables. Until power can safely be distributed wirelessly over a few meters distance, people will plug in.
2- The vast majority of users use 3.5mm jacks RIGHT NOW. Never mind the future, forcing so many people to change their habits to accomodate a new design is probably the pinnacle of User Experience bad practices.
If ever the universally standard jack comes to be superceded by new technology, it will happen gradually and naturally.
I could see, for example, a time when all devices anyone owns has USB-C connectors. Phones, computers, home entertainment, cameras... Maybe in 10 years time some people will be shopping for new headphones and realise they don't need to get the old jack style, all their devices have USB-C. Maybe 10 years after that, USB-C headphones are so commonplace that the value of retaining the old plug becomes questionable. Manufacturers weight the benefits of removing the plug against the lost sales from people still using the old technology, and the transition begins.
Instead we have Apple telling us now is the time, oh and we need headphones that happen to pay Apple license fees. And people are gobbling up the "new reality", making excuses for Apple "tech gets obsolete", "don't be a dinosaur"!
I mean I get that they make fantastic devices (this is the reason I'm so disappointed that I can no longer justify buying their products). But this is just a flat out terrible move, and one that is totally self-serving for Apple. I expect them to reverse this decision as their market share erodes over the coming years. We'll see.
1- It may sound silly now given the speed of evolution of technology in the past several years, but people will choose to use cords for 100s, even 1000s more years. As long as wireless devices need charging, a significant number of people will opt for cables. Until power can safely be distributed wirelessly over a few meters distance, people will plug in.
2- The vast majority of users use 3.5mm jacks RIGHT NOW. Never mind the future, forcing so many people to change their habits to accomodate a new design is probably the pinnacle of User Experience bad practices.
If ever the universally standard jack comes to be superceded by new technology, it will happen gradually and naturally.
I could see, for example, a time when all devices anyone owns has USB-C connectors. Phones, computers, home entertainment, cameras... Maybe in 10 years time some people will be shopping for new headphones and realise they don't need to get the old jack style, all their devices have USB-C. Maybe 10 years after that, USB-C headphones are so commonplace that the value of retaining the old plug becomes questionable. Manufacturers weight the benefits of removing the plug against the lost sales from people still using the old technology, and the transition begins.
Instead we have Apple telling us now is the time, oh and we need headphones that happen to pay Apple license fees. And people are gobbling up the "new reality", making excuses for Apple "tech gets obsolete", "don't be a dinosaur"!
I mean I get that they make fantastic devices (this is the reason I'm so disappointed that I can no longer justify buying their products). But this is just a flat out terrible move, and one that is totally self-serving for Apple. I expect them to reverse this decision as their market share erodes over the coming years. We'll see.