My Fireblade bodywork that I picked up at TJ's shop last night just happened to be the same colour as your wheels.....and looks fantastic I might add. When I dropped fairings off, I wasn't sure what shade of red I wanted........but once in his shop, I chose the colour based on the gorgeous Ducati rims that I spotted in his shop. I looked them over, and they were like glass! I was amazed that he even had the coating machined off of contact surfaces for a perfect installation on the bike. TJ is a very thorough guy indeed. Just made me happier I chose him to paint all 3 sets of fairings for me.
At the time I had no idea whose wheels they were, I just loved the colour and they looked better than OEM finish to me. Way better even than the Brembo wheels on my KTM.
Looks to me like someone was a little less than vigilant putting them into the trunk, or maybe tried to test fit them and dinged them against a caliper on the bike.....and is now trying to blame the workmanship instead of his own indiscretion and get a freebie.
Seems the orig poster has a habit of sourcing out work, accepting items back, happy enough with them to leave the shop...then afterwards, coming up with complaints and reasons to require a refund. Not a repair, a refund. If a customer is TRULY unhappy with a job, they would prefer a repair rather than a refund. Zebras and stripes and all that. And even though, in my mind that would qualify the customer as a theif of sorts, TJ even went way beyond his duty, sucked it up and gave you more money back than he kept? The money he kept wouldn't even pay for materials and machining.
Lets say, for conversation's sake, that I have already spoken to the last shop you posted a glowing review of, then later, you called him and threatened to post up a negative review if he didn't return at least $1000 to you? Many of us aren't new here, or new to motorcycles. Stop before you dig that hole any deeper. Go find a rock. Crawl under it.