kwtoxman
Well-known member
@kwtoxman is there a reason you only use uncooked in the shell shrimp?
I get the frozen packs of shrimp and have tried all iterations; I found through much experience that raw shelled shrimp is simply the best way to have great shrimp at home.
Raw shrimp cooked at home provides a much better texture; when cooked properly shrimp should be soft and supple, but not mushy, think al dente or a bit of firmness that gives way in a bite. Cooked shrimp reheated at home can't replicate the texture and it ends up notably tougher, granular and essentially overcooked.
Shelled shrimp provides a very effective barrier against the effects of the direct pan heat without adversely affecting its texture (again). It also helps to maintain the light but important shrimp flavour in a cook (as miggs posted).
Additionally, cooking raw shelled shrimp is also very quick, so it really isn't any more work than the other options. This makes it even more sensible to go with raw shelled shrimp.
Most people overcook shrimp, notably, so first thing to do is avoid this. I typically thaw shrimp out quickly in water (shelled shrimp also helps keep the flavour in the shrimp defrosted this way). After thawing, I heat up a skillet on less than half heat then add oil (I like peanut, but most cooking oils will do). I then put the shrimp in and cook them; even the gigantico shrimp I use typically only take 1.5-2 minutes per side, so don't get distracted. Small shrimp can be half that time; shrimp cook very quickly. After that I let the shrimp cool a bit and deshell them if a dish asks for or people prefer them out of the shell. The shrimp flavours and texture just ends up amazing. I found that this was great for next level shrimp cocktail too. Cook shrimp this way and let them cool for a few minutes longer before deshelling and serving. Don't rinse the shrimp after cooking (or deshelling); that removes flavour and the oil. Serve with seafood sauce (shrimp cocktail sauce) and enjoy.
I typically buy the larger shrimp because they are easier to cook well (not overcook) and are more forgiving in a cook. My previous posts used the 16-20 per pack size.
http://www.seriouseats.com/talk/2008/08/how-do-you-describe-texture-of-perfectly-cooked-shrimp.html
http://www.seriouseats.com/2015/08/how-to-pick-shrimp-varieties-freshness-guide.html
Hope it helps. With all of this I can now cook shrimp as well as I've ever had eating out at restaurants. And I can now really notice when a restaurant overcooks the shrimp.
Last edited: