What you're saying flies in the face of all insurance underwriting tables.
If it's NOT true, you should tell EVERY insurance entity in Ontario, cuz they're charging for it.
Insurance companies are NOT allowed to use "cancellations for non payment" to the MTO to rate a driver. "Cancellation for non payment" is considered a Administrative suspension, and administrative suspensions cannot be considered in rating UNTIL the suspension is over 23 months... then it's the lapse that affects the rate, not the suspension.
Cancellation of a insurance policy for non payment is a different matter. Cancellation of a policy for non payment is considered fraud and insurance companies don't like fraud.
And commercial driving experience doesn't apply?
How is driving the SAME car not experience?
When I bought motorcycle insurance, the speeding tickets i got in the cab sure did apply to the rating of the motorcycle insurance, the seat belt tickets did not. (And funny thing: when buying taxi insurance nobody cares that you have 4 small speeding tickets, cab drivers get tickets, but when applying for motorcycle or private car insurance you get treated like typhoid Mary if you have ONE)
When I bought motorcycle insurance I was asked if i had been in ANY at fault collisions/pay outs in the last 5 years... no exclusion of commercial driving, or private car driving.
For your average cab driver, a pay out for a collision doesn't go on their record because they don't own the car or the policy. In MY case, I DID own the car(s), I DID own the policies... and the pay out record of my many drivers went on MY insurance record too. If one of my drivers got into an at fault in one of MY cars, that went on MY insurance exposure, not the drivers.
Whether or not "experience" is accepted is up to the underwriter, not the broker.