Any GTAM'ers own an electric vehicle?

Forget the tires for a moment, the 'service' on a product without an engine or many if any moving parts is more then his previous Porsche. I think that's a fair critique, what on earth requires $100 more?

It would be interesting to know but I don’t believe a breakdown was provided.

It sounded like it may have been a mileage level inspection though, similar to how BMWs turn on the “service soon” indicator on their motorcycles at arbitrary mileages just to get “checklist” items done at a dealer. Sometimes those checklists appear to be a little more than “Spent 10 minutes looking over bike, all seems well, connected computer and cleared service interval indicator, $175 please.”

If there was actually stuff inspected based on interval (like how on a ice car something like the timing belt is a inspection interval item that is not inexpensive to have done on some cars), in that case it’s not really a fair one-to-one comparison to his Boxster in the end as there would have been labour involved in that process on the EV.

Until there’s an itemized list of what was actually done for that $800 were all guessing. Clearly *something* was done, but was it arguably unnecessary stuff? Did they charge him the $800 just to plug in the computer and check things out, or did they actually remove things and inspect stuff? Who knows. Does his other Porsche also need that same level of service as well at points in its mileage, ie my timing belt example, while the EV doesn’t at that point?
 
OK, seconds after I respond, Itemized list, didn’t see that in the video.

So, labour mostly it seems.

My comments stand on similar costs when his Boxster comes up to similar inspection milestones.
 
Screenshots just look like an inspection checklist, and the cost items pertained to tires (and nothing else) which were "attention in the near future".

That is a very extensive checklist. There's a whole lot of stuff on that checklist that have nothing whatsoever to do with an EV. Why is "Exhaust System/Catalyst" on there?
 
It would be interesting to know but I don’t believe a breakdown was provided.

It sounded like it may have been a mileage level inspection though, similar to how BMWs turn on the “service soon” indicator on their motorcycles at arbitrary mileages just to get “checklist” items done at a dealer. Sometimes those checklists appear to be a little more than “Spent 10 minutes looking over bike, all seems well, connected computer and cleared service interval indicator, $175 please.”

If there was actually stuff inspected based on interval (like how on a ice car something like the timing belt is a inspection interval item that is not inexpensive to have done on some cars), in that case it’s not really a fair one-to-one comparison to his Boxster in the end as there would have been labour involved in that process on the EV.

Until there’s an itemized list of what was actually done for that $800 were all guessing. Clearly *something* was done, but was it arguably unnecessary stuff? Did they charge him the $800 just to plug in the computer and check things out, or did they actually remove things and inspect stuff? Who knows. Does his other Porsche also need that same level of service as well at points in its mileage, ie my timing belt example, while the EV doesn’t at that point?
Not sure about BMW's in the past but my '20 had service requirements pop up in line with the scheduled maintenance plan in the manual. Not just some arbitrary come see us for no reason at all kthnxbai!
 
Screenshots just look like an inspection checklist, and the cost items pertained to tires (and nothing else) which were "attention in the near future".

That is a very extensive checklist. There's a whole lot of stuff on that checklist that have nothing whatsoever to do with an EV. Why is "Exhaust System/Catalyst" on there?
probably a generic template used across the board.
 
Not sure about BMW's in the past but my '20 had service requirements pop up in line with the scheduled maintenance plan in the manual. Not just some arbitrary come see us for no reason at all kthnxbai!

This is a well known phenomenon in the BMW world. I have a BMW riding buddy who does all his own maintenance who spent a bunch of money to get a special tool that allows him to clear the stupid “Service” light himself.

It comes on at arbitrary mileages.


There’s lots of cars that do the same thing at arbitrary mileages as well, although in many cases they at least correlate to legitimate major service items like timing belts or coolant system flushes.

 
This is a well known phenomenon in the BMW world. I have a BMW riding buddy who does all his own maintenance who spent a bunch of money to get a special tool that allows him to clear the stupid “Service” light himself.

It comes on at arbitrary mileages.


There’s lots of cars that do the same thing at arbitrary mileages as well, although in many cases they at least correlate to legitimate major service items like timing belts or coolant system flushes.

okay service light reset sure, ill concede.
 
probably a generic template used across the board.

Yep. Wonder if the pricing for that inspection accounts for all the stuff that doesn't need doing with an EV.

Dealers don't always have it together ... on the Bolt facebook groups, we have a chuckle when the dealers send out their form letter reminders with a coupon for an oil change.

I inquired at my dealer what their "EV Health Checkup" was about. "How many k's on it?" (about 40 000 at the time) The service adviser scoffed and said to bring it back when I had double that.
 
I inquired at my dealer what their "EV Health Checkup" was about. "How many k's on it?" (about 40 000 at the time) The service adviser scoffed and said to bring it back when I had double that.

Which is why many dealerships are not typically excited about selling EV‘s, and some are openly hostile – their regular service check ups for things like oil changes and such which are profit-pigs go away.

That’s money gone for them. So why would they be incentivized to sell an EV when they can sell a gas vehicle and then send service reminders every three months or 5000 km telling people that they need $100 service visits.

Seems like Porche has that figured out though - get customers to bring in their EV for catalytic converter and cam belt checks, and glance at everything basically. The brake pad check shows as “visual only” so they didn’t disassemble anything, and they didn’t even check the spare tire because it looks like the trunk was full.

Considering a lot of garages will do “brake checks“ for free in an effort to get the resulting work from vehicles that actually need them, I don’t really see much else on this list that justifies an $800 bill unless there was more we didn’t see honestly.
 
Back
Top Bottom