To Censor or not to Censor? | Page 2 | GTAMotorcycle.com

To Censor or not to Censor?

Bring politics or religion into a thread in ADVrider and you'll find yourself in band camp very quickly.
I was on a KLR forum and the mods were like "we don't care the topic as long as it's respectful". Turns out what they meant was "respectful to rednecks from red states that LOVE guns and trump". When I VERY respectfully pushed back instant band camp action.
 
I was on a KLR forum and the mods were like "we don't care the topic as long as it's respectful". Turns out what they meant was "respectful to rednecks from red states that LOVE guns and trump". When I VERY respectfully pushed back instant band camp action.

"Freedom for meee but not for theee"
 
At a point , and it’s has happened on forums , even with a user name , people have been held responsible and accountable in court for things said on a forum . Scott Tempesta , owner of a forum about 300 times larger than this one settled for millions in a slander suit .
Censorship in many cases is to keep legal dept happy. An open forum is not open season.


Sent from my iPhone using GTAMotorcycle.com

Most of the complaint was for things said outside of the forum..
Scot Tempesta said those things himself..
The things said were outright accusations of theft/fraud, etc..
 
Bring politics or religion into a thread in ADVrider and you'll find yourself in band camp very quickly.

Since the sale to a company it is this way. Before, it was way better, where people could have conversations without fear of being banned. I always referred to that site as a place for adults to go, whereas I find this site to be way too PG.
 
Bring politics or religion into a thread in ADVrider and you'll find yourself in band camp very quickly.
There is a guy that surfaces on ADVrider who calls himself Mack Knife. He appears to be a redneck of the highest order who is constantly looking to pick a fight. If the sky is blue he says it's red. They keep filtering him out and he just comes back for more. Wouldn't you think he'd get the message ?
 
I was on a KLR forum and the mods were like "we don't care the topic as long as it's respectful". Turns out what they meant was "respectful to rednecks from red states that LOVE guns and trump". When I VERY respectfully pushed back instant band camp action.
As a reformed KLR rider I can attest to the fact that they are 'special'. They went to special school on the special bus... ;) ;) ;)
 
Isn't redneck a derogatory term?
 
Some might consider it a compliment.

Some consider the N word a term on endearment, but would you use it? Lots of double standards, its pretty easy to just not put people down for their background/culture aye.
 
Growing up my parents made it clear that if unprovoked I should watch my Ps and Qs and if I thought someone would get offended by my comment, to keep it to myself.

Now, (thanks to the left), you can’t say ‘banana bread’ without someone feeling slighted.

Pretty sad
 
Now, (thanks to the left), you can’t say ‘banana bread’ without someone feeling slighted.

Pretty sad

But if you use the term redneck, outside of the odd SJW, no one will bat an eye.
 
Growing up my parents made it clear that if unprovoked I should watch my Ps and Qs and if I thought someone would get offended by my comment, to keep it to myself.

Now, (thanks to the left), you can’t say ‘banana bread’ without someone feeling slighted.

Pretty sad
My mother used to make banana bread to get us to eat rotting produce. I'm offended.
 
Good discussion. It's important to hear how we are doing. It's not an easy task.
Thanks all.
I can appreciate how much work it is to moderate a forum. Years ago I volunteered as a mod on a Network 54 Kids Hockey forum -- it was a gong show. We had great tools, I could track posters by IP or login, get notifications when certain bad apples were posted or online, and set alerts based on threads, posters, and keywords.

A daunting task, I ended my volunteering after a few months.

For this forum, I'd do the following:

1) Decide whether this is a Subject Matter forum about Motorcycles or a Community forum for Motorcyclists. I suspect it's going to be the latter as there isn't enough subject matter on Motorcycles to keep the forum going.

2) Review the ground rules, and revise if necessary. The existing rules are fine, but a bit vague, probably by design. I would say that most topics sent to Trash are not a clear violation of TOS. I'd review the last 20 Trashed threads against the existing TOS, then try to form a reasonable argument as to which of the terms was violated. It that proves difficult, you have a disconnect to between moderation and TOS. I suspect it will be difficult.

I like the phrase: "For further clarity, ..."

3) If the discussion is wandering into dangerous territory, fire a warning shot, or zero out the content of an offending post before killing the discussion.

My 2 cents.
 
There is a guy that surfaces on ADVrider who calls himself Mack Knife. He appears to be a redneck of the highest order who is constantly looking to pick a fight. If the sky is blue he says it's red. They keep filtering him out and he just comes back for more. Wouldn't you think he'd get the message ?
He got the message. He gets his energy from conflicts. Filtering, banning and criticism are just sparring techniques that hone his fetishes. It's like fighting with a pig. Everyone gets covered with mud and the pigs love it.
 

Back
Top Bottom