That is your problem. The flasher relay requires a certain amount of current going through it in order for the relay to pull in and open the contacts (they flash by opening, closing, open, close, etc). Your LED signals draw so little current that - to the flasher relay - it looks like an open circuit. The relay that opens the circuit can't pull in because there isn't enough current through it for the relay to operate.
Do a search on "load resistors".
It is not that your signals all need to be the "same". It is that the total current demand from all the bulbs has to be the same (or close) as stock.
Do a search on "load resistors".
It is not that your signals all need to be the "same". It is that the total current demand from all the bulbs has to be the same (or close) as stock.