Last year, when I was looking at Buells, there was a 2007 Lightning posted for $4,700 for an entire season. At the end, asking price was dropped to $4,000. It sat there for another couple of months before disappearing.
I purchased a 2009 1125r for $3,400 with 14,000km on it. There were people in GTA asking 6-7K. Some of those ads were up for over a year...
Buells are uncommon but they are also not sought after. Look at the average views per posting on Kijiji. Some of them have less than a 100 views after several days...
Better market south of the border though.
With that said - Lightning XB12 probably holds value best of all the Buells (aside from the Ulysses version).
I'd say you got lucky Neil.
I still wanna get another Buell down the line. Wish our insurance system didn't penalize us so heavily for owning multiple vehicles.