Wouldn't banning a known scammer be in the best interest of the website as well as the honest members that make up this website?
There is a much, much better alternative. More on this in a moment ...
It's a sketchy line to draw, there's always two sides to every story and I sure as hell wouldn't want to be the one that listened to both and had to determine which one gets kicked out.
OP could post his experience and let the other person respond (or not respond) and let community sentiment determine the outcome. In the past this has backfired on some members as they weren't nearly as innocent in the sketchy transaction as they felt.
BINGO.
Post the facts ... tell the truth ... let the chips fall where they may.
If there are repeated reports of incidents involving a particular person, and they are made public, and the facts of the cases stand up to scrutiny (which WILL happen) ... that is a far better method of outing a scammer than banning them - which would lead to them continuing their scamming activities by other methods.
Based on what evidence? I doubt GTAM has either the resources or desire to act as mediator between two aggrieved parties. I also doubt they want to make themselves responsible to any degree for the transactions that occur every day here. The classifieds section works best "as-is" with no assurances from the board.
Exactly.
If you look in the "reviews" section, and do some digging and searching, you can find out what businesses and people you want to deal with, and who you don't want to deal with.
If there is a consistent pattern of warnings and poor reviews for a certain business or member ... it's probably best to stay away.
But there have been many times that a forum member complains about a business or some other member, and the complaint has proven to be off base because of facts that were conveniently omitted, and the real problem was with the complainant themselves.
If there are 10 good reviews for 1 bad, or if numerous people come to the defense of the business being complained about ... then people can make their own decisions.
Its rare that a scammer just does their thing once, usually they run the same scam over and over again...
Yep ... so make the facts public.