New Router needed

lil sushi

Well-known member
Site Supporter
So my new roomie has a macbook...

I'm not a big Apple fan...goes against my religion...

He hates my Linksys.

I can't find a perfect harmonic decision on a new router...any suggestions other than Linksys, cisco, or apple products would be appreciated.

Keep in mind between the two of us we've discussed a budget of 100 for this.

Thanks for any help/suggestions offered.
 
What's he attempting to do that causes this "HATE" of that particular piece of equipment?

Connectivity issues etc?
 
What's he attempting to do that causes this "HATE" of that particular piece of equipment?

Connectivity issues etc?

My Linksys has not been happy since I moved it...intermittently dropping the signal apparently. I'm never home, but when I'm there it seems to work fine with my netbook.
 
Linksys makes terrible products. I often wonder why Cisco is trying so hard to lend their good name to it. In case you didn't know, Linksys is owned by Cisco.

As far as recommendations are concerned you can't go wrong with D-Link or Asus brand routers they are quite good. Keep in mind that wireless signals are effected not only by the physical location of the router but also the type of building materials used in the dwelling. Wireless is one of those things that will work if you throw enough money at it; investing in additional access points helps spread the signal out.

Also be aware that just like with other devices routers (regardless of brand) occasionally have updated firmware released for them. The firmware updates can resolve a variety of problems and shouldn't be ignored, so whichever you choose double check that you are using the latest version. Many routers have a limited period of free installation support, that is why it is better to get everything taken care of within the first few days of purchasing the router.

Good luck!
 
Buy another linksys and upgrade your firmware with this

http://www.google.ca/?q=linksys+tomato+firmware

and btw its "affected"

Linksys makes terrible products. I often wonder why Cisco is trying so hard to lend their good name to it. In case you didn't know, Linksys is owned by Cisco.

As far as recommendations are concerned you can't go wrong with D-Link or Asus brand routers they are quite good. Keep in mind that wireless signals are effected not only by the physical location of the router but also the type of building materials used in the dwelling. Wireless is one of those things that will work if you throw enough money at it; investing in additional access points helps spread the signal out.

Also be aware that just like with other devices routers (regardless of brand) occasionally have updated firmware released for them. The firmware updates can resolve a variety of problems and shouldn't be ignored, so whichever you choose double check that you are using the latest version. Many routers have a limited period of free installation support, that is why it is better to get everything taken care of within the first few days of purchasing the router.

Good luck!
 
Have a look here as well.
http://www.dd-wrt.com/site/index

I use Linsys routers for almost 10 years now but for last 5 or so I use dd-wrt firmware.
In my house I have combination of Macs, PC running windows and LInux and don't have any issues.
 
I have a linksys wrt54g (v8 firmware). I have an iPhone, iBook and MacBook Pro running on wireless, on wired i have a dlink NAS. all connect fine. however I am having issues with dns periodically timing out for a minute or two. open connections like irc stay connected but anything like web and mail are unusable until dns comes back. I'd used my airport extreme base station but something either in the airport firmware or my wireless modem firmware changed and they have become incompatible so I just use the airport to provide gigabit routing between the nas and other gigabit devices (macbook pro), printer/usb hdd connectivity and wireless A/N connectivity, the linksys I use for B/G connectivity and to connect 10/100Mb hard wire connections (xbox, etc when plugged in).

How ever, linksys has been known to have some incompatibilities with certain computers and appliances, I no longer have the list (I don't handle those sort of complaints anymore).

this is the one Firestart recommended me (but it needs to be flashed to a different operating system

http://canadacomputers.com/product_info.php?cPath=27_365&item_id=014864


t
his is the one i'm thinking of picking up as i have a futureshop gift card

http://www.futureshop.ca/en-CA/prod...spx?path=8350c80b2e98ba0c093494858abcf4dfen02

the second one has N wireless probably on the B/G/N band, i'd still run my airport on the A/N band giving me full coverage.
 
So my new roomie has a macbook...

I'm not a big Apple fan...goes against my religion...

He hates my Linksys.

I can't find a perfect harmonic decision on a new router...any suggestions other than Linksys, cisco, or apple products would be appreciated.

Keep in mind between the two of us we've discussed a budget of 100 for this.

Thanks for any help/suggestions offered.

Is Sushii your roommate?
 
If your router used to work, til you moved it, it probably isn't a router problem.
Meaning if you bought a new router and put it in the same place, the new one would probably have the same problems.
Try moving your router first or get a better antennae.
As consumer crap goes, there is nothing wrong with linksys.
Tell your room-mate to stuff his/her mac, it IP networks just the same as everybody else. One leg at a time.
 
I am betting it's a chipset "incompatibility" issue.. Since the move, there's either more distance and/or more obstacles between her computer and your router. If your Linksys has a Broadcom wireless chipset and her Mac has Atheros, I can see how that can turn into problems with marginal signal and/or more interference from the neighbors' wireless networks, cordless phones and microwave ovens. Before you go shopping for a new router (and I can certainly help you choose something that'll meet your needs), what's the exact model and version of that Linksys router? Typically it would be along the lines of WRT160N v2 (a real crappy one ;)) and it would be on the sticker on the bottom of the router. Also, which netbook do you have and which exact Mac computer does your roommate have? At best we can solve your problem with a firmware flash, a bit of carboard, scotch tape and tinfoil. At worst, we can hit the ballpark of your budget.
 
I am buying new router every year or so and went through pretty much all brands. My last purchase was netgear -quite happy with it and you can find one for well under $100
 
I am buying new router every year or so and went through pretty much all brands. My last purchase was netgear -quite happy with it and you can find one for well under $100

Dude.. That's like saying that a Yamaha, any Yamaha will meet a particular rider's needs. There's a difference between an R1 and a Virago. Same goes for routers.. You need to look at the wireless chipset, at the CPU, RAM, flash memory.. They are literally mini-computers. Ironically there is a Netgear at the top of my list as well (WNDR3700).. 680MHz (monster by consumer router standards), 64MB of RAM, dual band wireless. In the 120-130+HST ballpark. The 5GHz band is less prone to interference, but it has less obstacle-penetrating power.

To save a few bucks, I'd probably recommend a TP Link TL1043ND ($70 ballpark) and a directional antenna. Also Atheros-based, 400MHz/32MB of RAM. It just depends on the wireless chipset of the client devices.

I am personally using an ASUS RT-N16, with 480MHz CPU and 128MB of RAM, Broadcom chipset, $90 range. I have owned and/or worked on all 3 and quite a few other routers, so I know my stuff when it comes to consumer gear.
 
Gotta say I don't really agree with any of you. Linksys is ****ing garbage. Plain and simple. The suggestions here assume a level of end user knowledge that isn't realistic. Next everyone will be recommending people go for $30,000 Cisco routers, a SAN, fiber switches and their own cabinet with an integrated HVAC unit. :roll: If the OP buys a router and flashes it with the linux firmware it will immediately void the warranty and entitlement to support.

Most people don't even know enough to lock-down the security on their router; if it wasn't integrated to the setup CD's which ship with the router many people still wouldn't be doing it. Anyone with enough technical abilities to flash the Linksys router with a linux OS should just skip right to pfSense or M0n0wall. But then if most people have those abilities they wouldn't be asking for help to begin with. I don't mean any disrespect, just making a point.

If anyone is considering a consumer level router such as an Asus or a D-Link unit they should opt for a unit which has 2+ antennas to help with the signal. A single antenna unit will only offer limited coverage. As much as I like both of those brands, even they need a couple of antennas to be useful.

Also worth noting is that the N speed wireless sometimes only works as advertised when you're using specific hardware. For example, lets say you buy a D-Link N router but use the integrated wireless card on your laptop, you'll only get the performance of whatever the laptop is equipped with. In order to get the "full experience" as advertised you would also need to buy a D-Link N standard wireless card or usb device.

Plus, the full speed of the wireless only matters if you were transferring massive files across between your computer and another laptop or device on the same network. Otherwise the only benefit of using the N standard is the somewhat improved range. Mixing brands of wireless and trying to achieve the N performance won't work very well either, so wherever possible try to use the same brand of equipment.

Edit: This also looks like a bit of fun to try, I'd be interested to know what effect (that's for you Petraeus :p) it has on the signal. http://www.wikihow.com/Make-a-Wi-Fi-Booster-Using-Only-a-Beer-Can
 
Last edited:
apple tends to use broadcom, at least that's in my mbp

In that case, ASUS would be the best choice. The main reason I bought it instead of spending a few extra bucks on a much more powerful platform was the bcm chipset. Most of our computers have bcm-based wireless adapters. With that being said, I'd try a cheap fix first.. This one worked well while it was temporarily needed (better than the CANtenna suggested in this thread): http://www.freeantennas.com/projects/template2/index.html
 
Have a look here as well.
http://www.dd-wrt.com/site/index

I use Linsys routers for almost 10 years now but for last 5 or so I use dd-wrt firmware.
In my house I have combination of Macs, PC running windows and LInux and don't have any issues.

I have an old WRT54G (one of the most popular Linksys models) and it was starting to freeze up where I needed to reboot it manually. This was a huge inconvenience for the days I needed to access my server from somewhere else.
Threw on DDWRT and it has been running perfectly fine ever since, going on 2 years now.
 
Gotta say I don't really agree with any of you. Linksys is ****ing garbage. Plain and simple. The suggestions here assume a level of end user knowledge that isn't realistic.

The OP works in IT support, the suggestions are realistic for someone with her experience.
 
Is Sushii your roommate?

LOL...Real helpful..thanks...and no...that would be too coincidental and easy no?

new roomie is an old friend from back in the CNS days...figured it would save us both moula in the city...woot woot...

but seems like buying all this extra crap is starting to offset any potential savings LOL
 

Back
Top Bottom