Nobody likes paying for fuel but it is my humble opinion that most people over-weight the effect of the fuel economy of their vehicles. If you can ballpark your mileage for the next X years, you can build the price of fuel into your vehicle and have a more straightforward comparison.
I wanted to suggest M-classes but it looks the manuals weren't popular or available here.
My dad has a 2nd gen Silverado (extended cab, 6.0L/6AT/4x4) that reset a lot of my expectations of pickup trucks. It's no Miata but handling is shockingly direct and predictable, goes forward pretty good, back bench is reasonably comfortable for adults, has a part-time mode for the 4x4... parking it still sucks for me (he has zero trouble threading the needle downtown, but he used to drive service trucks for Toronto Hydro). Neither of us were a fan of the Z71 suspension it came with, but when he replaced it with an aftermarket setup the difference was remarkable.
Pretty much the exact same drivetrain in a Pontiac G8 GT (which he also owns)
I wanted to suggest M-classes but it looks the manuals weren't popular or available here.
Something to consider. I have limited space though and a 4 seater pickup tends to get pretty long. I live in the city and go downtown a lot so the length makes parking a problem. Don't love the handling on most pickups either but I'll keep it in mind.
My dad has a 2nd gen Silverado (extended cab, 6.0L/6AT/4x4) that reset a lot of my expectations of pickup trucks. It's no Miata but handling is shockingly direct and predictable, goes forward pretty good, back bench is reasonably comfortable for adults, has a part-time mode for the 4x4... parking it still sucks for me (he has zero trouble threading the needle downtown, but he used to drive service trucks for Toronto Hydro). Neither of us were a fan of the Z71 suspension it came with, but when he replaced it with an aftermarket setup the difference was remarkable.
Pretty much the exact same drivetrain in a Pontiac G8 GT (which he also owns)