You molded rubber parts before? I'm impressed at the flexibility of that 3D printed part. A lot of the "cost" in the 3D printing is someone putting in the time to make the computer model (and test parts/modifications). If you are just paying for machine time and filament, that is a lot lower number.
For me it would be re-inventing the wheel, experimenting with materials that would do the job but be makable without tools that would set me back the price of a Toronto house. In that sense items made before plastic are easier to copy. Metals, wood and leather are easier to work than a lot of plastic.