It's been said earlier, I think the pricing has more to do with quality of materials and R&D. I had a bottom-feeder HJC a while back. Bobbed my head around quite a bit compared to my present Scorpion (which didn't cost alot either). Putting them side by side though you can see the difference the extra $200.00 went.
Also, all this talk of helmet protection. I think the protective difference would be in a rather aggressive crash - and really, would it make that much of a difference considering all the elements involved?
Sorry though I couldn't add any "real" feedback on an actual experience with the Evos.
This is true and it all depends on circumstances. In the handful of times I went down street and track I never touched my head down. Its obviously because of the way I fell and I guess I usually stayed with the bike so I didn't go flying...So I guess I'd have been just fine in anything. Safety wise, but then there's long term usage and comfort/reliability.
My helmet which was RF-1000 I bought in 2009 was just
retired this season. I still sent it to Shoei for a check up and to have the snap button thingy on the chinstrap replaced, it finally wore out after 75,000km. They said its in 'poor cosmetic condition' (after dozens little falls off the mirror or being blown off the seat, mostly my stupidity), but the shell had not been impacted and the EPS liner had not been compromised, other than in the chin area it was a little depressed from years of hanging it off the mirror. Due these reasons and its age they suggest I replace it.
So mechanically its still good, and I just replaced the cheekpads in 2012 so its relatively fresh. I will just use it a track helmet or backup. I liked it so much I picked up another one in the same graphics when I was lucky enough to find on kijiji, just because...That's my actual backup to the new RF-1200.
Point being....had this been some cheap helmet I don't believe it would have held up nearly as well, replacement parts would probably have been impossible to get, and I wouldn't have the confidence to keep on wearing it after so long.
It cost me 620 after taxes, so it came to about $125 a year, the service was free, I'd rather invest in that than having a piece of **** every other year.