NealT
Well-known member
Agree with what's being said for the most part, bike fit is most important. FullMotoJacket will know what you need given his posted past experience and bike collection. Suspension is a non-issue at this point, set a firm budget and get a good fitting bike. For your stated price the component spec level may be similar but given components in good working condition your frame fit is priority one along with a good saddle (not the gel junk that gets sold at Walmart/Can tire). Of course factor in where you will ride, how intense.....etc. You will be surprised where roadie type bikes can go off road and vice versa what mtb bikes can do on road given a quick tire change.