Both are supposed to have the reverse current protection, so perhaps it's defective?
I'd do tests to see if there's a draw on the battery with the bike just sitting however first - charge the battery back up and disconnect the tender and see if it gets depleted again, or if you have an amp meter wire it inline on the positive cable with the ignition off and see what it shows for milliamp draw.
I'd do tests to see if there's a draw on the battery with the bike just sitting however first - charge the battery back up and disconnect the tender and see if it gets depleted again, or if you have an amp meter wire it inline on the positive cable with the ignition off and see what it shows for milliamp draw.