Bradley smoker is a really great piece of kit. But all it does is smoke. But that's all its designed to do, so it does it very well, the Bradley has been around for years and the guide is really idiot proof, no real guess work about over smoking, temps and timing. It's very consistent and that can produce less waste in the long run because you don't get inedible product. Part of the charm of charcoal smoking is the process and learning curve, but there is something to consistent results.